Ghost
stories
The remains of an American soldier
is pictured being carried on board a plane at the Da
Nang International Airport in central Vietnam. Picture taken June 24,
2009. Tuoi Tre
HANOI – As I
listened to the speeches at the Sheraton Hotel the other night, as the
dignitaries from the US and Vietnam commemorated the 25th anniversary of
joint efforts to find traces of American servicemen who vanished in the war,
my thoughts drifted to another day more than 20 years ago.
I was at film set near Los Angeles
that portrayed the red-light district of war-time Saigon
for a TV series called "Tour of Duty." Somehow, the set had been
enlisted by a group of Americans bound together by a profound sense of loss
and betrayal, convinced that something more sinister than war itself was
preventing them from learning the fates of hundreds of American servicemen
who did not return home from Vietnam,
Laos and Cambodia.
"If I give you my husband's bracelet," said
Marian Shelton, sitting behind me in the audience, "will you wear
it?"
She meant the POW-MIA bracelet engraved with his name.
I was a teenager when about 5 million bracelets engraved with the names of America's
POWs and Missing In Actions were distributed. The war had divided America
politically but people on both sides hoped for an end and a return of the
POWs and resolution of the MIAs. Many people vowed to wear the bracelet until
the serviceman came home, or his fate was resolved.
Marian's husband, Col. Charles E. Shelton, was a
special case. He was shot down over Laos during a secret
reconnaissance mission in 1965, and was known to be taken prisoner by Lao
forces. The prevailing judgment, short of definitive evidence, was that he
had died, yet he would be the last U.S. serviceman officially
classified as a POW. Marian disputed suggestions that Charles' unique
classification had been a political gesture by the Air Force and the Reagan
Administration – as a symbol of hope and solidarity with the activists.
Marian was gracious as I awkwardly declined her offer.
I didn't tell her that, to me, the bracelet would have simply been a
journalistic souvenir, not a keepsake.
Perhaps no other people, in no other war, have been
more obsessed with a war's unaccounted for casualties than Americans were
with its losses in Vietnam.
Actually, the number of American KIA/BNR – killed in action, body not
recovered – was relatively small, a tiny fraction compared to the Americans
who vanished in Korea
and the two world wars. At the time of the Paris Peace Accords in 1973, the U.S. listed
1,350 POWs (with an uncertain number believed to have died in captivity) and
sought the return of the remains of 1,200 missing. Meanwhile, Vietnam
estimates its unaccounted for casualties from the war as exceeding 300,000 –
and that doesn't include those who lost while fighting alongside Americans in
the war here.
Certainly Americans would have been less obsessed if
their forces prevailed, and there wasn't the sense that the lives were lost
in vain. The post-war politics was thick with emotion, and the POW-MIA cause
also sprouted a cottage industry, much of it sincere and much of it the
cynical and venal work of charlatans, sometimes both at once. My coverage for
the Los Angeles Times included a profile of one former Air Force
officer who, after winning acclaim for his work with refugees, raised
millions of dollars for dubious missions that produced bones he claimed to be
human but were determined to be those of pigs. He didn't get most of the
money; the professional fundraising firm took the biggest cut of the action.
Today, I'm told, the charlatans tend to Vietnamese who rip off their
countrymen by selling bones and artifacts that they claim will help them get
money or visas from U.S.
officials. A woman from Da Lat is said to have recently spent about $120,000
on a large collection of bones – and forensic analysis showed that none were
those of American servicemen.
The biggest bucks were made by Hollywood, with Sylvester Stallone's
"Rambo" topping a spate of POW rescue fantasies that sold plenty of
popcorn and soda, as well a vicarious notion of American redemption.
My "military brat" upbringing, as the son of
a career Marine, may have drawn me to the story. I felt for families who had
lost loved ones and wanted answers. But I also understood that the eternal
flame at the Tomb of the Unknowns, erected in Arlington National
Cemetery after the
First World War, represented the fundamental truth that, in war, some answers
may never be obtained.
Hearing the speeches in that ersatz Saigon so long ago,
it may have been hard to imagine that the U.S.
and Vietnam
had already started working together to investigate and excavating crash
sites, finding remote burials and repatriating remains. To many POW-MIA
activists, obsessed with conspiracy theories, this was just a window-dressing
for an elaborate cover-up. One man, himself a former POW, spoke of recent
aerial spy photos depicting "tall shadows" – American shadows, he
insisted, of men still held prisoner. Covering the quixotic movement, it
occurred to me the activists possessed a zeal that was practically religious.
If a missing man could be found alive and returned, it would have been like a
resurrection.
Hundreds of families, however, have received a measure
of closure through the process, and the efforts are credited with building
trust between the former enemies. U.S. Ambassador David Shear spoke about how
the joint investigation starting in 1988 "laid the foundation" for
a new relationship between the nations. Diplomatic relations were normalized
in 1995. Shear noted that, while working to resolve the MIA cases, the U.S. also
helps support the removal of unexploded ordnance, the clean-up of Agent
Orange and provides aid for the disabled. The value of two-way trade between
the countries in the past year exceeded $25 billion, and more than 15,000
Vietnamese are now studying in the U.S.
Over the 25 years, there have been 112 joint missions
to recover remains, often in extremely difficult terrain, and hundreds of the
missing have been positively identified. It's considered the greatest effort
to account for lost servicemen in the history of warfare, and advances in DNA
analysis have helped.
For Americans who were stuck between denial and anger
in the classic process of grief, the obsession could have a terrible cost.
Some months after she offered me her husband's bracelet, Marian Shelton took
her own life in the backyard of her San
Diego home while wearing a St. Jude, the patron
saint of lost causes. Twenty-five years had passed since her husband
disappeared. Her hopes had been raised and dashed many times, often by other
believers in the cause spreading rumors. She had carried the burden of the
POW-MIA movement, and the pressure led to depression and alcoholism. Four
years later, at the request of Marian and Charles' five children, the last
POW was reclassified as killed in action. The Shelton family wanted to finally put the
war behind them.
Over dinner, Ha Kim Ngoc, Vietnam's Vice Minister of
Foreign Affairs, reminded everyone that the joint mission itself has come at
a great human cost as well. In 2001, nine Vietnamese and seven Americans
participating in the MIA investigation were killed in a helicopter crash in
2001 in Quang Binh Province.
At Ha's suggestion, we stood to observe a moment of
silence to honor their sacrifice.
Scott Harris, Tuoitrenews
|
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét