Vietnamese television journalist
blasted for fashionable appearance in Syria documentary
Le
Binh (wearing a pink T-shirt) and her team pose with Syrian government soldiers in this photo posted on one of the crew members'
Facebook on July 8, 2016.
A documentary by national
broadcaster Vietnam Television, which claims to report the "Syria
conflict from the inside," has had its credibility questioned, with many
believing the program was staged.
The
coverage, entitled “News Feature Story on Syria – A View from Inside the
Conflict,” which aired on VTV24 on July 23, told audiences how lead
journalist Le Binh, a cameraman and two other reporters had experienced the
ongoing conflicts in the West Asian country.
During the
33-minute program, Binh, who is also VTV24’s director, detailed how her team
had cheated death on three occasions during their time in Syria.
However, two
of the three stories have been doubted by local viewers as either exaggerated
or completely staged using inaccurate information concerning what is really
going on in the war-torn country.
Many viewers
also questioned the credibility of the program generally, with Binh donning
fashionable clothes, including various brightly-colored T-shirts and hats,
and even sunglasses while she was walking through the rubble of destroyed
homes or reporting from inside a secret tunnel used by government forces.
Critics also
said that the reporting contained far too much emotion instead of facts. Binh
appears too often, is seen crying and being startled by gunfire many times
throughout the war-themed documentary. The narrative tone of the report is
also criticized as "overly pathetic."
Narrow escape from death?
According to Infonet, a newswire run by the Ministry of
Information and Communications, one Vietnamese Facebook user named Kim Nhu
Hoang has provided a detailed analysis proving that Binh’s claims of having
cheated death three times in Syria were false on two occasions.
Less than
three minutes into the report, Le Binh is seen walking on a deserted street
in the city of Homs, pointing to the west saying “on that side, the Islamic
State is still in control.”
According to
Hoang, the western side of Homs is currently controlled by opposition forces
including the FSA and Al-Nusra, but not IS.
“And the
inner-city of Homs is in a near peaceful situation now, despite the rubble,”
he wrote.
The second
occurrence of “facing death,” as reported by the feature, was when a bomb
placed inside a Catholic church in the town of Maaloula exploded just 30
minutes after the VTV24 team had left.
This detail
is refuted as inaccurate by Hoang as there was no report of a bomb explosion
at a church during July, when the documentary was produced.
The last
time the team supposedly faced death was when they were inside an underground
tunnel in Jobar, an area some 2km northeast of the Syrian capital of
Damascus, when a hail of bullets, which Binh said came from a rebel force,
fired on them.
There are
also scenes showing tanks firing in the report, which raises doubts as to
whether most of the documentary was filmed in safe areas with no ongoing
conflicts.
“It is like
a video diary of an adventurous trip to a conflict-hit area, rather than a
war documentary from the Middle East,” Infonet wrote, quoting another Facebook
users comment.
Le Binh (wearing sunglasses)
‘We were not acting’
Under
increasing pressure from the public, Binh and her VTV24 team held a press
conference on Wednesday in the hope of silencing their critics.
Binh
admitted that they had picked up “non-professional clothing” for the trip,
but added that the local man who guided them around Syria said that “Homs is
a safe area where you can wear anything you want.”
Addressing
the question as to why the scenes showing her crying were not cut during
editing, Binh said the feature report “had to be embedded with emotions.”
“We knew
people would say that we were ‘acting’ then, but omitting those scenes would
have reduced the credibility of our report,” Binh said.
“We kept
those scenes as those were our real feelings no matter what people say.”
This scene of Le Binh's crying is said to be unnecessarily long.
As for those
who doubt the number of times they cheated death in Syria, Binh said they
have evidence for all three cases.
Despite the
title given to the program “from inside the conflict,” Binh said at the press
meeting that the main goal of their trip was to interview people, including
victims and government soldiers.
There are in
fact some scenes of tanks firing and of gunfights, which Binh claims were all
real.
“So you
think we, a media team from Vietnam, could ask the Syrian defense force to
set up those fight scenes for us?” she asked the assembled media.
Binh said
she would never return to Syria, “as long as conflict remains there.”
TUOI TRE NEWS
|
Thứ Tư, 27 tháng 7, 2016
Đăng ký:
Đăng Nhận xét (Atom)
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét