Note on dog fighting (a
prayer for Michael Vick)
I love dogs. One of my best friends in the world
was a dog who would could somehow sense when I had a bad day at school and
would lie by my side, looking up occasionally with sympathetic eyes. She
would howl to songs when i was moved to sing. She would sing with me.
I also love
It wasn't this recent dog-fighting controversy that
first brought about the thought that these two loves might not be completely
compatible. It occurred to me only a few weeks after I arrived here: I was
walking down the street, Hang Dao, casually, behind two young guys. These
gentle-looking fellows were walking arm in arm, quietly chatting as
Vietnamese men are so pleasantly wont to do.
I was watching them, just thinking that men don't walk
this way in the
Then something strange happened. A dog came roving
modestly the opposite way. As they passed, one of the men, just as casually
as they were speaking to each other, kicked the dog. Hard.
The dog yelped and kept going. The two men laughed and
continued their conversation in the pleasant
This, in
That was only the first of many, many incidents of
animal cruelty I have seen in
After some years here, I find there is something
distasteful to me about the sanctimonious way in which western visitors and
tourists would like to 'educate' Vietnamese people about the treatment of
animals.
This is because most of us come from lands of relative
luxury, in which we can afford not lo live with animals, not to treat them as
tools or things. We come from places where all the animals we know either
have names or are served on plates.
We have the luxury to dissociate one from the other, in
fact. We don't remember the times when the family cow, who we saw reared up
from a calf, was fattened and ready to eat - the reason it was born, after
all. Then someone would go out to slaughter that cow, and the family would
eat well.
I think we should keep this in mind when criticizing
Vietnamese people on their treatment of animals. Maybe we should remember
that we have the luxury of dissociating the cruelty that occurs in our large
industrialized ranches and slaughter houses, which we never have to look at
if we don't want, and not many of us do, from our comfortable lifestyle, diet
and daily activity.
We can have animals as pets, giving them cute names,
loving their quirky characteristics, taking funny videos of them and posting
them on Youtube. Then we can sit down and have a nice chicken dinner. Maybe
even feed a bit of your delicious chicken to your dog as a treat.
But it's not so nice to think about the fact that the
chicken was raised... well you know already, don't you? We just don't like to
think about that. We are animal lovers, right? Much easier to be
self-righteous. (Vegetarians, your hands are not clean either, though brevity
forbids going into that).
The point is that, fighting animals for fun sucks. Yes.
I don't think any sane person would argue with that. In fact, the reaction by
the Vietnamese to these dog fights shows the same. But the mindset that makes
it possible for people to get pleasure out of participating in it should not
be relegated to a nationality. That kind of cruelty exists everywhere.
Most especially, those most extreme animal rights
critics from western countries should never forget that our nations are
probably the worst when it comes to the torture of animals.
Dog fighting should be stopped. So should drone
strikes, trade embargoes, etc. Where is our moral compass really?
By Brian Webb | dtinews.vn
|
Thứ Tư, 12 tháng 3, 2014
Đăng ký:
Đăng Nhận xét (Atom)
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét